Aphid-resistant soybean varieties for Minnesota
Soybean aphid is an invasive pest of soybean that continues to cause economic damage in Minnesota.
To prevent economic loss, producers commonly apply foliar insecticides when aphid densities reach 250 aphids per plant.
For Minnesota soybean producers, yield loss and control costs can be significant.
Aphid-resistant genes (Rag genes)
Using aphid-resistant soybean varieties holds promise as a more sustainable approach to soybean aphid management.
Soybean varieties that possess resistance genes, called Rag genes (Rag1, Rag2, etc.), affect colonization and population growth of soybean aphid (Figure 1).
Soybean varieties with Rag1 or Rag2 genes have significantly suppressed aphid numbers and protected yields in multiple states over multiple years. Varieties with multiple (i.e., pyramided) Rag genes can provide further protection.
Independent university research has shown that varieties can have Rag1 and Rag2 genes without reducing yield (e.g., Figure 2), compared to similar aphid-susceptible soybean lines not under aphid pressure.
For example, the study shown in Figure 2 found the resistance genes did not cause yield drag in soybeans. The 2016 Rosemount study compared the yields of soybean varieties IA2104 (aphid-susceptible) and IA104RA12 (Rag 1 + Rag 2 pyramid) with low aphid pressure (less than 20 average aphids per plant, at most) during the growing season.
Resistant varieties offer season-long protection from aphids. In contrast, insecticidal seed treatments (neonicotinoids) only provide temporary protection up to about 40 days after planting. This is typically before aphid populations establish.
Using resistant varieties also reduces the likelihood of needing to apply foliar insecticides for soybean aphid.
Availability of aphid-resistant soybean
Commercial varieties containing Rag genes have been available since 2009, but are uncommon among early-maturity soybean varieties developed for Minnesota.
We searched seed catalogs and identified several soybean varieties with aphid-resistance (Rag) genes in early-maturity groups and with other traits potentially suitable for Minnesota soybean growers. Table 1 lists these varieties.
|Brand names||Company||Relative maturity||Resistance gene(s)||Herbicide resistance trait||PRR1||SCN1||IDC1||SDS1||BSR1||Organic seed|
|0543||Gold Country Seed||0.5||Rag1||RR 2Y2||Susceptible||Resistant||–||–||–||No|
|1114||Gold Country Seed||1.1||Rag1||RR 2Y2||Resistant||Resistant||–||–||–||No|
|LS 10R551N||Legend Seeds||1.0||Rag1||RR 2Y2||Resistant||Resistant||–||–||–||No|
|NS1040NR2||NorthStar Genetics||1.1||Rag1||RR 2Y2||Resistant||Resistant||–||–||–||No|
|3511 R2YN||Thunder Seed||1.1||Rag1||RR 2Y2||Resistant||Resistant||Tolerant||–||–||No|
|Viking 0.1544AT||Viking Seeds||1.5||Rag1||None||–||Susceptible||Tolerant||–||–||Yes|
|Viking 0.1955AT||Viking Seeds||1.9||Rag1||None||Tolerant||–||–||–||Susceptible||Yes|
|Viking 2188NAT||Viking Seeds||2.1||Rag1 and Rag2||None||–||Resistant||–||–||–||No|
|Viking 0.2188AT12N||Viking Seeds||2.1||Rag1 and Rag2||None||–||Resistant||–||–||–||Yes|
|Viking 0.1IA2104RA12||Viking Seeds||2.3||Rag1 and Rag2||None||–||–||–||Resistant||–||Yes|
|Viking 0.2399AT12N||Viking Seeds||2.4||Rag1 and Rag2||None||–||Resistant||–||–||–||Yes|
1PRR: Phytopthora root rot; SCN: Soybean cyst nematode; IDC: Iron deficiency chlorosis; SDS: Sudden death syndrome; BSR: Brown stem rot
2RR 2Y: Genuity Roundup Ready 2 Yield
Continue to scout for aphids
It’s important to continue scouting for soybean aphids because they can occasionally reach damage levels on resistant plants.
Soybean aphid populations (biotypes) that can overcome aphid-resistance genes exist, but their occurrence varies from region to region and year to year.
While soybean varieties with single resistance genes, such as Rag1 alone, have effectively suppressed soybean aphid in Minnesota, varieties with pyramided resistance genes, such as Rag1+Rag2, offer more robust protection from resistance-breaking aphid biotypes.
Planting well-adapted aphid-resistant varieties could improve the sustainability of soybean production.
Brace, R.C. & Fehr, W.H. (2012). Impact of combining the Rag1 and Rag2 alleles for aphid resistance on agronomic and seed traits of soybean. Crop Science, 52, 2070-2074. https://doi.org/10.2135/cropsci2011.12.0637
Cooper et al. (2015). Geographic distribution of soybean aphid biotypes in the United States and Canada during 2008-2010. Crop Science, 55, 2598-2608.
Hanson et al. (2016). Sources of soybean aphid resistance in early-maturing soybean germplasm. Crop Science, 56, 154-163. https://doi.org/10.2135/cropsci2015.05.0287
McCarville, M.T. & O’Neal, M.E. (2013). Soybean aphid (Aphididae: Hemiptera) population growth as affected by host plant resistance and an insecticidal seed treatment. Journal of Economic Entomology, 106, 1302-1309.
McCarville, M.T. et al. (2014). One gene versus two: A regional study on the efficacy of single gene versus pyramided resistance for soybean aphid management. Journal of Economic Entomology, 107, 1680-1687.
Reviewed in 2018